Phil's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Wantagh, New York

Phil’s Pizzeria & Restaurant stands as a beloved establishment in Wantagh, New York, offering a comprehensive dining experience for a wide range of tastes and preferences. Located at 1378 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh, NY 11793, the restaurant is easily accessible and provides a welcoming atmosphere for both casual and special occasions. A readily available phone number is 62217773, and visitors can explore the full menu and learn more about the restaurant’s offerings on their website: http://philspizzeriarestaurant.com/.

About Phil’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

At its core, Phil’s Pizzeria & Restaurant is a dedicated pizza restaurant, specializing in crafting high-quality pizzas with a variety of toppings and crust styles. However, their menu extends far beyond pizza, encompassing a diverse selection of comfort food, appetizers, entrees, and desserts. The restaurant prides itself on using fresh, locally sourced ingredients whenever possible, contributing to the exceptional taste and quality of their dishes. They cater to a broad clientele, from families enjoying a relaxed dinner to individuals seeking a quick and satisfying bite.

Key Features and Services

• Dine-in: Guests can enjoy their meals in the restaurant’s comfortable and inviting dining area.
• Takeout: For those on the go, takeout service is readily available, allowing customers to conveniently pick up their orders.
• Delivery: Phil’s offers delivery services to surrounding areas, bringing the restaurant’s delicious food directly to their customers’ doorsteps.
• Curbside Pickup: A convenient option for those preferring to avoid entering the restaurant.
• Fast Service: The restaurant is known for its efficient and friendly service, ensuring a pleasant dining experience.
• Extended Hours: Catering to various schedules, they offer lunch and dinner service.
• Accessibility: Phil’s is committed to inclusivity and offers wheelchair accessible entrances, parking, restrooms, and seating, demonstrating a dedication to accommodating all patrons.
• Payment Options: Accepts a wide variety of payment methods, including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, providing flexibility for customers.
• Amenities: Wi-Fi is available, creating a comfortable environment for guests to connect.

Customer Feedback and Reputation

Phil’s Pizzeria & Restaurant has garnered a strong positive reputation within the community, as evidenced by its impressive 272 reviews on Google My Business. The average opinion is 4.2/5, reflecting the overwhelmingly positive experiences shared by its patrons. Many reviews highlight the restaurant's friendly staff, delicious food, and welcoming atmosphere. Specifically, numerous customers have praised the restaurant's responsiveness to special requests, such as catering for events like Christmas meals. One particularly touching review describes how Phil's stepped in to save a family’s Christmas celebration after unforeseen circumstances prevented them from cooking, providing a delightful array of food that was widely praised by their guests. This demonstrates a genuine commitment to customer satisfaction and a willingness to go above and beyond to meet their needs.

Menu Highlights and Offerings

Beyond their signature pizzas, Phil’s Pizzeria & Restaurant boasts a diverse menu that includes a selection of appetizers, such as mozzarella sticks and garlic knots. Entrees feature classic comfort food favorites like pasta dishes, sandwiches, and salads. Desserts provide a sweet ending to the meal, with options ranging from cheesecakes to cookies. They also offer a range of beverages, including alcohol, beer, and coffee, catering to different preferences. The restaurant’s dedication to providing options for various dietary needs is evident in their vegetarian options, appealing to a broader customer base. Furthermore, they cater to smaller appetites with quick bites and small plates, perfect for sharing or individual enjoyment. The restaurant also offers catering services for events, further solidifying its position as a versatile and reliable dining destination.

The restaurant’s atmosphere is generally described as casual and cozy, creating a comfortable environment for families, groups, and individuals. It is widely considered family-friendly, with high chairs and a dedicated kids’ menu available. They are also known to be LGBTQ+ friendly and transgender safespace, fostering a welcoming environment for everyone. The restaurant is exceptionally accommodating, offering free parking lot and free street parking, along with on-site parking for added convenience. Dogs are permitted outside, adding to the welcoming atmosphere.

👍 Reviews of Phil's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Kimberly C.

5/5

I had to come on and publicly thank Phil’s for catering our Christmas meal with very short notice . I was released from hospital and very upset about not being able to cook and I called Phil’s and they were amazing! The food was absolutely delicious our guests kept asking where the food was catered from. Thank you all at Phil’s for saving our Christmas with a delicious array of food !

Thomas T.

4/5

Phil's is a local pizzeria restaurant in Wantagh. The staff are friendly and the premises is clean and is decorated lovely!
There is a wide variety of specialty slices to choose from: buffalo chicken, rigatoni vodka, honey dijon chicken, etc as well as many others.
They also have soups, salads, pastas and heros to choose from!
Definitely worth stopping by if are looking for a slice!

Arv

1/5

I miss the old Phil’s. When I’m eating your pizza which the price of it has increased but the quality decreased I’m being attacked by flies. I swear there or more flies then people. And especially the booths they are always filthy. I swear your prices increase every week. You should go back to the old ways. The restaurant used to be so nice, no flies, food cheaper and miles better, service better (Leo is very nice tho) and also Zeppoli used to be far better and cheaper.

Scott K.

1/5

Made the mistakes of ordering here instead of Massapequa. They must not be affiliated at all. Easily the worst pizza I have ever eate; we had to throw it away. The "grandma" slices were unrecognizable and oddly rectangular instead of square. Stay clear and just drive the 4 minutes to the one in Massapequa.

anthony

1/5

I went to Phil’s with my friends just to grab a quick slice. I was surprised that there were more flies in the establishment than people. There were also hundreds of crumbs lining the edges of the booths with gluey oil on the table. Prices will raise a dollar per week as Phil needs to pay the bills. It doesn’t end there. I handed the cashier a 5 dollar bill for a 3.50 purchase and he takes it without me insisting to keep the change. Keep in mind there is no service here other than providing the food (no waitress/busboy). I returned to my greasy booth, down $1.50, and began to inspect my pizza which had an oil bath prepared for the flies. That’s all that needs to be said—you get to decide whether or not to eat here.

Robert D.

5/5

The large greek salad with grilled chicken is delicious and very filling.

Barry S.

5/5

I kept driving by Phil’s and I stopped in to try it. I ordered one plain slice and it was excellent! I was shocked how good it was. The restaurant is clean and help is nice. Go stop in and try a slice, you will like it.

Charlie W.

5/5

Honestly, food is good. I do not usually sit down and eat at pizzeria, but I never felt well treat it as Karlos did.